Request a Quote

Ready for a better insurance partner for your agency?

Let us show you the difference that nonprofit expertise can make. First Nonprofit® can help you get what your organization needs.

We know no two nonprofits are the same. We are eager to get to know you. When you request a quote from First Nonprofit®, you will be contacted within 2 business days by one of our representatives to begin the work of learning about your agency so that we can produce a strong portfolio of coverage.

We offer a host of nonprofit-tailored products and services available through the First Nonprofit® family.

Testimonials

“First Nonprofit Insurance Company knows the major issues which face nonprofit organizations and does its utmost to keep the organization protected and our exposures down. Its claims services are excellent. Prompt responses are the norm. As well, any time there are questions relating to our coverages, they respond a timely manner.”

Mary Lynne Januszewski, The Chicago Lighthouse for People Who Are Blind or Visually Impaired

“We have been insured with First Nonprofit for many years. First Nonprofit has been a wonderful organization for Family Focus to partner with in providing great advice and expertise in risk management. I would highly recommend First Nonprofit for any type business.”

Caterina Varvaro, Family Focus

“I appreciate how First Nonprofit understands the needs of nonprofits and the idiosyncrasies associated with delivering social services to vulnerable populations.”

Paul W. Hamann, The Night Ministry

“We are very pleased with the unique worker’s compensation [coverage] both due to the fairness of rates and understanding of methodology in establishing our premiums.”

Gerald Gulley, SHORE Community Services

“While providing us with reasonable premiums, it has also assisted us with programs relating to loss control and, through routine site visits, has provided us with ongoing updates relating to all areas of safety.”

Mary Lynne Januszewski, The Chicago Lighthouse for People Who Are Blind or Visually Impaired

“The company was our carrier when we had a budget of $2.5 million and has grown with us and supported us as we grew to an annual budget of more than $5.5 million.”

Paul W. Hamann, The Night Ministry

“It is good to know that other nonprofits [in new states] might now be able to take advantage of First Nonprofit’s excellent customer service and insurance coverage.”

Paul W. Hamann, The Night Ministry

“We hope First Nonprofit will continue to maintain its high standard of service and assist nonprofit agencies like CASL [Chinese American Service League] that have large exposures and to continue to offer services to minimize our risks and keep our premium affordable. We hope to continue this partnership for a long time.”

Esther Wong, Chinese American Service League

“Within two hours of submitting our claim electronically, we received a call from your claims department and the settlement process was quickly assessed and handled. Our director of safety was very impressed and called me specifically to comment on the great work by your staff.”

Chuck Stadler, Goodwill Industries of Southeastern Wisconsin

“Through the years, as the agency expands to meet service needs, it has not been easy for CASL [Chinese American Service League] to balance its operational costs and, at the same time, provide quality services. We’ve found that First Nonprofit Insurance Company shares similar goals with us. Your wide and encompassing coverage, affordable and competitive premium, as well as a highly professional team have met our insurance needs for over a decade.”

Esther Wong, Chinese American Service League